As a pastor and church planter, I’ve discussed the differences between Catholicism and Protestant Christianity countless times. Recently, I joined ministers Isaiah Saldivar, Pastor Vlad Savchuk, and Apostle Alexander Pagani for an in-depth conversation on this topic. I’ll share my perspective on the seven key differences we identified, drawing from our discussion and my experiences as a Protestant pastor with Italian Catholic roots.
We do not intend this discussion to cause division or belittle anyone’s faith. Our ultimate goal aims to point people to the truth found in Jesus. We believe examining these differences can help believers grow in their understanding of God’s Word and deepen their relationship with Him.
We must approach this topic with humility. Sincere believers exist in both Catholic and Protestant traditions. We don’t seek to judge or condemn but to encourage thoughtful reflection on biblical teachings. As we explore these differences, I invite you to consider them prayerfully in light of Scripture. Always seek the Holy Spirit’s guidance in your pursuit of truth.
We’ll examine various doctrines and practices, comparing them to our understanding of biblical teachings. We hope this examination will deepen your appreciation of the gospel and strengthen your faith in Jesus Christ, the Way, the Truth, and the Life.
1. Praying to Saints: A Controversial Practice
One of the most significant differences between Catholicism and Protestant Christianity is the practice of praying to saints. As Protestants, we believe that prayer should be directed solely to God. The Bible instructs us to pray to the Father through Jesus Christ, empowered by the Holy Spirit.
Catholics, on the other hand, teach that there’s value in praying to deceased saints who can intercede on our behalf. This practice, however, is not found in scripture. In fact, it could be seen as a form of necromancy, which is prohibited in the Bible.
From my perspective, this practice undermines the sufficiency of Christ as our mediator. As 1 Timothy 2:5 states, “There is one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus.” By praying to saints, we risk creating a spiritual hierarchy that isn’t supported by scripture.
2. The Eucharist vs. Communion: Understanding Transubstantiation
Another major difference lies in the understanding of communion. In Catholicism, the doctrine of transubstantiation teaches that the bread and wine literally become the body and blood of Christ during the Eucharist. This is seen as a re-presentation of Christ’s sacrifice.
As Protestants, we view communion as symbolic. We believe that when Christ said, “It is finished” on the cross, He meant it literally. The idea that a priest can repeatedly “crucify” Christ through the Eucharist is, in our view, problematic.
I believe this doctrine can inadvertently diminish the role of the Holy Spirit. Instead of recognizing Christ dwelling within believers through the Holy Spirit, it can lead to an overemphasis on external, physical representations.
3. Confession: To Priest or to God?
In Catholicism, confessing sins to a priest is a sacrament. Catholics believe that priests have been given authority by Christ to forgive sins, based on their interpretation of John 20:21-23.
As Protestants, we believe in the priesthood of all believers and that confession should be made directly to God. While James 5:16 encourages us to confess our sins to one another, this is for accountability and support, not for forgiveness, which comes from God alone.
This practice, in my view, can create an unnecessary intermediary between the believer and God. It may also lead to a dependence on human authority rather than fostering a direct relationship with God.
4. Holy Relics: Objects of Veneration or Idolatry?
The Catholic Church places significant importance on holy relics – objects associated with saints or Christ himself. These might include the rosary, crucifixes, holy water, or statues of saints.
As Protestants, we’re cautious about such practices, seeing them as potential violations of the second commandment against creating or worshiping idols. While God can use physical objects (as seen in scripture with items like Paul’s handkerchiefs), we believe it’s problematic when these objects become the focus of veneration or are seen as means to draw closer to God.
In my pastoral experience, I’ve seen how easily well-intentioned practices can slip into idolatry. Our focus should always be on Christ and the indwelling Holy Spirit, not on physical objects.
5. The Afterlife: Heaven, Hell, and Purgatory
A significant theological difference between Catholicism and Protestantism is the concept of purgatory. Catholics believe in an intermediate state where souls undergo purification before entering heaven.
As Protestants, we believe that upon death, believers go directly to be with the Lord (2 Corinthians 5:8), while unbelievers face judgment. We don’t find biblical support for a “middle ground” or waiting room.
This doctrine of purgatory can lead to practices like praying for the dead or giving financial donations to speed up a soul’s purification. From a Protestant perspective, these practices can detract from the sufficiency of Christ’s atonement and potentially exploit people’s grief for financial gain.
6. Salvation: Faith Alone or Faith Plus Works?
Perhaps the most crucial difference lies in our understanding of salvation. The Catholic Church teaches that salvation involves faith, baptism, good works, and remaining in good standing with the church.
As Protestants, we believe in salvation by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone. Ephesians 2:8-9 clearly states, “For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works, so that no one can boast.”
This difference is not just theological hair-splitting. It impacts how believers view their relationship with God and can significantly affect their spiritual and emotional well-being. In my pastoral work, I’ve seen how a works-based understanding of salvation often leads to guilt, shame, and a constant feeling of inadequacy.
7. Baptism: Sacrament of Salvation or Symbol of Faith?
Finally, there’s a significant difference in how we view baptism. In Catholicism, baptism is seen as a sacrament that cleanses original sin, which is why infants are baptized.
As Protestants, we view baptism as a public declaration of faith, performed after a person has made a conscious decision to follow Christ. We don’t believe baptism itself saves a person or washes away original sin – only the blood of Jesus can do that.
This difference reflects our broader understanding of salvation and the nature of faith. We believe that faith must be personal and conscious, not something that can be imparted to an infant who cannot yet understand or choose.
Conclusion: Bridging the Gap with Love and Understanding
As I reflect on these differences, I’m reminded of the importance of approaching these discussions with love, respect, and a commitment to biblical truth. While we may disagree with Catholic doctrine on these points, it’s crucial to remember that many sincere believers are found within the Catholic Church.
My hope in sharing these differences is not to create division, but to foster understanding and encourage all believers to examine their faith in light of scripture. As Protestant Christians, we believe in the principle of Sola Scriptura – that the Bible is our ultimate authority in matters of faith and practice.
At the same time, we must be careful not to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Many beautiful traditions and practices within Catholicism can enrich our faith when properly understood and aligned with scripture. For instance, the emphasis on community, the reverence for God’s holiness, and the rich history of theological reflection are all aspects we can appreciate and learn from.
As we navigate these differences, let’s do so with grace, always seeking to point people to the sufficiency of Christ and the transforming power of the gospel. After all, what unites us – our faith in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior – is far greater than what divides us.
In the end, our goal should be to foster a vibrant, personal relationship with God through Jesus Christ, guided by the Holy Spirit and grounded in the truth of God’s Word. That, I believe, is the heart of true Christian faith, whether Catholic or Protestant.
Join the Breakers Creator Academy for only $30/mo if you use this link now: https://shorturl.at/46zYT
Download The Breakers App to take courses and find community with believers like you! https://mikesignorelli.com/the-breakers-app/